Metal Roofing vs Other Commercial Roofing Materials

Feb 2, 2024

When it comes to commercial construction, the choice of roofing material plays a pivotal role in defining a building's aesthetics, durability, and energy efficiency. Among the plethora of options available, metal roofing stands out for its robustness and cost-effectiveness. However, how does it stack up against traditional roofing materials like wood shingles, clay, and stone tile? Follow along as we compare the pros and cons of each so that you can make the best for your commercial property.

A Brief Overview of the Different Types of Roofing Materials

Before we do any comparisons, let's take a closer look at the different types of roofs available. When it comes to commercial roofing, there are several common options, each with its advantages and disadvantages:

1. Metal Roofing: A modern choice known for its strength, longevity, and eco-friendliness.

2. Wood Shingles: Exude a timeless charm, often preferred for their natural appearance.

3. Clay Roofing: A classic choice, offering a blend of durability and traditional aesthetics.

4. Stone Tile: Synonymous with luxury, these tiles offer unmatched longevity and style.

Now that we have a better understanding of the different types of commercial roofs, let's compare metal roofing to the other types mentioned, based on four key factors: durability, cost, energy efficiency, and aesthetic compatibility 

Metal Roofing vs. Shingles

1. Durability: 

Metal roofs are often made of steel, aluminum, or copper, and are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions like heavy rains, strong winds, and snow. They are also resistant to fire and pests, contributing to their lifespan of 40-70 years. Wood shingles, though aesthetically pleasing, are vulnerable to rot, insects, and fire, and typically last about 20-30 years with proper maintenance.

2. Cost: 

When it comes to the cost of metal roofs vs shingles, it depends on the type of material you choose. In general, metal roofs tend to be more expensive upfront than shingles. However, there are a wide variety of different types of shingles available, with some being more expensive than others. If you choose a high-end shingle, it can be more expensive than a basic metal roof. That said, metal tends to have a longer lifespan than most shingle materials, which could save you money in the long run on repairs and replacements.

3. Efficiency: 

Metal roofs excel in energy efficiency. Their reflective surfaces can significantly reduce cooling costs by deflecting solar heat. Wood shingles, on the other hand, while providing better insulation than metal, do not reflect heat, leading to higher energy costs in warmer climates.

4. Aesthetic Compatability: 

Metal roofing offers versatility in design, and is suitable for both modern and traditional architectures. Wood shingles, however, are typically used in traditional or rustic styles, given that they are made from natural materials.

Metal Roofing vs. Clay Roofing

1. Durability: 

While both metal and clay roofs boast impressive longevity, metal roofing often has the edge in withstanding more severe weather conditions without cracking or breaking, unlike clay tiles. However, clay tiles can last up to 100 years if maintained properly.

2. Cost: 

Clay tiles are generally more expensive than metal roofs, both in terms of material and installation due to their weight and the need for additional structural support. Metal roofs offer a more budget-friendly option in the long term with lower maintenance and repair costs.

3. Efficiency: 

In terms of energy efficiency, metal roofs are superior due to their ability to reflect solar heat. Clay tiles, though they offer decent insulation, tend to absorb heat, which can increase cooling requirements in hot climates, such as San Antonio.

4. Aesthetic Compatability:

Because metal roofing is so simple, and comes in a range of styles and finishes, it can easily adapt to various architectural styles. Clay tiles, on the other hand, have a distinct, traditional look, and are best suited for Mediterranean, Spanish, or Southwestern-style buildings.

Metal Roofing vs. Stone Tile

1. Durability: 

Stone tiles, often made of slate, are incredibly durable, sometimes lasting over 100 years. They’re also resistant to fire, rot, and pests. While metal roofing is also fire and weather-resistant, it tends to last between 50 and 70 years at most. While it is, in fact, durable, it usually doesn’t match the lifespan of stone tiles.

2. Cost: 

Stone tile roofing is among the most expensive options due to the cost of materials and the complexity of installation. Metal roofing is also an investment, but it’s typically more affordable than stone tiles.

3. Efficiency: 

Stone tiles, though excellent insulators, can contribute to higher heating and cooling costs due to their thermal mass. Metal roofs, in contrast, are much more energy-efficient due to their reflective properties. 

4. Aesthetic Compatability:

Stone tile roofing is a premium choice, often used in high-end, luxury constructions. It offers a unique, natural look that ages beautifully. Metal roofing, on the other hand, is also very versatile in design and can complement a wide range of architectural styles, from industrial to contemporary.

In Summary: The Best Roofing Material for Commercial Construction

Based on the analysis above, you may be wondering what roofing material would be the most suitable for your specific commercial building. While the "best" roofing material for your specific project should ultimately align with your building's architectural style, budget, and functional requirements, metal roofing often stands out as a particularly advantageous option. Its relatively long list of pros vs cons makes it a highly preferred option for commercial roofing projects. Plus, whether you're considering a metal roof vs shingles, clay, or stone tile, the adaptability and modern advancements in metal roofing offer solutions that can complement any design while providing unparalleled longevity and performance.

Get Help Choosing the Best Roofing Material For Your Commercial Project

As we've seen above, the choice of roofing material is a significant decision for any commercial property, impacting not just the building's appearance but also its long-term resilience and efficiency. In San Antonio, where the climate and local architecture add further layers to this decision, it's essential to work with a roofing expert who understands these nuances.

This is where Cloud Roofing shines. With our extensive experience in San Antonio commercial roofing, we can help you choose the best roofing material for your property. Or, if you already have a specific type in mind, we can advise you on the most suitable material options for that type, while taking into account your specific needs.

Get in touch with us today to discuss your roofing project and find out how we can help you make the right choice. We look forward to hearing from you!

Contact Us Today For Your Free Quote!

Cloud Roofing offers free inspections and quotes on all of our roofing services. If you think your roof may require repair or replacement, reach out to us today!
Free Quote
(210) 366-9484